Memories of My Father, Dr. Sunil Pandya

My early memories of Dr. Sunil Pandya — our Papa — date back to our family quarters in the Assistant Dean’s Bungalow at King Edward VII Memorial (KEM) Hospital in Parel, a Mumbai suburb where we lived from 1972 to 1998. Papa was a guiding force in our family’s life and right from the start, he was invested in his children’s education and personal growth. I vividly recall Papa helping with my schoolwork, encouraging me to go beyond just accepting what I was being taught – exhorting me to delve deeper, by asking “why” and “how.” He was very supportive of my childhood hobbies — from stamp and coin collecting, then to wildlife conservation, and later on to my sporting endeavours. For instance, when he recognized my interest in wildlife, he made me a life member of the World Wildlife Fund and gifted me a subscription to Sanctuary magazine. A few years later, he would buy me my first bicycle — ‘Hero’ was a popular brand at the time — and was happy to see me become increasingly proficient at cycling and going on to compete in races. He watched with amusement as I would routinely dis-assemble the bicycle, upgrade its parts and put it back together.

In our home, Papa’s love for reading was ever-present. After dinner, he would immerse himself in books, magazines, and newspapers, ranging from National Geographic and Time to an eclectic assortment of literature. In particular, Papa was a lifelong student, and teacher, of medical ethics. Despite long days at the hospital, sometimes including marathon 12+ hour surgeries at KEM, he always found time for his family and to quench his thirst for learning about all manner of things.

Once, while on a family holiday to the Kanha National Park in the late 1970s, he orchestrated an impromptu study of a giant ant hill. He convinced some locals to cross section the structure, upon which he studied it, photographed it and published his findings in an article for Sanctuary magazine. On another instance, I recall his meticulous preparation for a presentation on “Hindu Philosophy on Pain” at a conference in Germany. His months of research and painstaking assembly of slides culminated in a highly praised lecture. His connections with the international medical community not only advanced his own knowledge but also enriched KEM Hospital’s capabilities.

Remarkably, Papa never imposed his own aspirations on me. When I chose to not pursue a medical education, but rather to study engineering in the U.S., he was entirely supportive. He trusted me to make informed decisions and to pursue excellence — always celebrating achievements, big or small. Despite our physical distance after I moved to America in 1990, he remained engaged in my life, often surprising me with insights about my own interests and career, which I had not yet grasped.

All the while, Papa continued to develop his beloved Neurosurgery department at KEM. I recall the time when, through the connections of my uncle, he was able to secure sponsorship from the Tatas for a department computer — a rarity in the 1980s — to enhance services to patients and students. Over the years, his dedication to public service remained strong, even as he transitioned to private practice at Jaslok Hospital following his retirement from KEM at age 58.

The move to private medicine was, I believe, a difficult adjustment for Papa. He often spoke of the ethical dilemmas that troubled him—families forced to weigh the significant financial burdens of quality medical care, against the slim chances of a loved one’s recovery. Although he didn’t complain of it, it was evident that private practice lacked the intellectual and altruistic fulfillment that KEM provided to him. His heart remained with the teaching hospital where he could serve a broader community and mentor young doctors.

Papa’s intellectual curiosity flourished in the digital age. Embracing personal computing and the internet, he became a devoted Mac user, diving into research and writing.

In their second act, he and my mother were finally able to travel widely and explore many parts of the world, documenting their adventures through thousands of photographs enriched with detailed presentations for family and friends. Each journey became an opportunity to marvel at our world’s wonders, whether through the lens of history, geography, or culture.

In his later years, despite physical setbacks, Papa remained active with his daily walks, but was most often found at his computer. The age of the internet allowed him to channel his passion for learning and sharing knowledge.

On October 3, 2024, he sent an ominous email to close friends and family about a major health setback. For a man who rarely acknowledged personal health issues, his message was alarming. Soon after, he experienced the rapid progression of pulmonary fibrosis. Following a brief hospitalization and a few weeks of palliative care at home, our dear Papa passed away on December 17, 2024.

The outpouring of love and gratitude over the past days, from those whose lives he touched speaks volumes about his character and legacy. Walking into his bedroom now, without him at his desk, feels surreal. Yet, his presence is everywhere—in the values he fostered in us, and the numerous lives he influenced.
My family and I cherish Papa’s wisdom, kindness, and unwavering support. His impact on our lives and the lives of so many others will continue to resonate, a testament to a life lived with purpose and compassion.

In Remembrance of Dr. Sunil K. Pandya

It is with profound sadness that we announce the passing of Dr. Sunil Krishnalal Pandya on 17th December 2024. Dr. Pandya was the former Head of the Department of Neurosurgery at KEM Hospital and Seth GS Medical College, Mumbai, and the inaugural Chair of Medical Humanities at Seth GS Medical College.

Born on 11th February 1940 in Santacruz West, Mumbai, Dr. Pandya was an alumnus of Grant Medical College and Sir J.J. Group of Hospitals, where he earned his MBBS in 1961 and MS in General Surgery in 1965.

Dr. Pandya received his neurosurgical training under the esteemed mentorship of Dr. Gajendrasinh at J.J. Hospital and Dr. Homi Dastur at KEM Hospital. His commitment to advancing his expertise took him to the Institute of Neurology, London, and the Institute of Child Health at Great Ormond Street, London, as a Commonwealth Medical Scholar in 1974–75. His global exposure included learning from renowned neurosurgeons such as Professors M.G. Yasargil, Madjid Samii, and Kenichiro Sujita.

Dr. Pandya’s passion for the history of medicine was inspired by the guidance of Dr. Ashok Vaidya (KEM Hospital) and Dr. Samuel J. Aptekar (Gokuldas Tejpal Hospital). For many years, he enriched the education of first-year MBBS students at Seth GS Medical College through his lectures on the history of anatomy.

A prolific scholar, Dr. Pandya authored numerous publications in scientific journals, popular press, and scholarly platforms, addressing topics in neurosurgery, the history of medicine, and medical ethics. He served as the Emeritus Editor of the Indian Journal of Medical Ethics and contributed to the editorial boards of the National Medical Journal of India and Mens Sana Monographs.

The Department of Neurosurgery at KEM Hospital, known nationally and internationally for its excellence in patient care, record-keeping, and neurosurgical training, owes much to Dr. Pandya’s vision and leadership.

Beyond neurosurgery, Dr. Pandya was deeply committed to medical ethics and humanities. He was instrumental in establishing the Forum for Medical Ethics and its respected publication, the Indian Journal of Medical Ethics. His pioneering efforts laid the foundation for the Department of Medical Humanities at Seth GS Medical College, which continues to shape future generations of medical professionals.

Dr. Sunil Pandya was a teacher par excellence, a mentor to countless physicians, and a beacon of medical ethics. His legacy is an enduring source of inspiration for the medical fraternity, and he will be remembered for his unparalleled contributions to medicine and humanity.

May his soul rest in eternal peace.

A Homage to Dr. Sunil Pandya: Mentor, Visionary, and Friend

Archana and I had the privilege of closely interacting with Dr. Sunil Pandya during the founding of GOSUMEC Foundation USA, starting in June 2022. From the very beginning, our conversations centered on the Foundation’s history pages, where I sought his invaluable guidance and access to a wealth of materials. Dr. Pandya meticulously proofread every line of the website, offering thoughtful suggestions and sharing resources that greatly enriched its content and appeal. His immense pride in the Foundation’s achievements was palpable, as was his tireless readiness to assist—whether through a quick phone call or his prompt responses to countless emails.

Even the Foundation’s logo reflects his thoughtful input. He took the time to educate us on the difference between the accurate Asclepius symbol and our alma mater’s Caduceus emblem, ensuring that we represented it with precision and integrity.

Our bond grew stronger over shared passions—Medical Humanities and his unwavering commitment to Student Welfare. Whether through phone calls, emails, or a memorable tea meeting at his charming home with his wife Shubhada, our exchanges were always enriching. That meeting stands out vividly, as we delved into The History of Our Alma Mater, a book that was a labor of love for Dr. Pandya and one that will undoubtedly become a treasured legacy for GOSUMEC alumni.

Dr. Pandya’s steadfast support shone through during discussions about the challenges of growth. He championed our commitment to transparency and accountability, urging us to resist political pressures while maintaining the dignity of our alma mater. His unwavering belief in our mission strengthened my resolve and confidence in the path we were charting.

Just days before his passing, we shared a heartfelt phone call about the progress of the GOSUMEC Foundation USA Scholarships—our Pay It Forward initiative.

Today, I am confident that Dr. Sunil Pandya would feel immense pride knowing that GS Medical College and KEM Hospital has become the first medical institution in India where all need- and merit-based students can benefit from the GOSUMEC Foundation USA Scholarships through a U.S. alumni endowment that will serve generations to come.

To me, Dr. Pandya was more than a mentor—he was a friend. While he insisted that I address him as “Sunil,” I embraced this familiarity only reluctantly, out of deep respect for the extraordinary individual he was.

His profound words continue to inspire us, weaving nostalgia and pride into a tapestry that unites generations of GOSUMEC alumni—heart to heart, through his timeless pen.

Soon, you too will be able to relish his final masterpiece, a book chronicling the history of our alma mater in celebration of its centenary. This work stands as a testament to his enduring legacy and the greatness of his soul.

Dr. Sunil Pandya, as I Remember

Think of all the superlatives to describe the most desirable attributes in a man—honesty; being ethical, truthful, and friendly; professionalism and brilliance—now think of a man upon whom to adorn a garland of those superlatives. That would be Dr. Sunil Pandya, who died on December 17, 2024. We are all so much poorer from his demise. 

As I sit in a California residence of my son, penning my memories of Sunil, I dig through the mines of my memory. They take me go back to 1969. I first met Sunil that year, on the 2^nd floor neurosurgery ward of the KEM Hospital in Parel. Just then I was the happy recipient of an ICMR-funded job as Assistant Research Officer (ARO) to work under Dr. Anil Desai on projects related to muscular dystrophies in children.  In one sense, Dr. Desai was an oddity—an honorary neurologist in a neurosurgery department. As we entered the ward, we saw Sunil at the front desk entering notes into the medical records of his patient. I believe he had recently joined the department as assistant professor and worked under Dr. Homi Dastur.

I learned that my “office” was a desk in one room in the neurosurgery office/library/medical records room rolled into one. I shared my office with Dr. Desai, two neurosurgery residents and Sunil. Professionally, my work did not overlap with that of Sunil, who a neurosurgeon and I, an MD postgraduate student registered under the legendary Professor of pediatrics, Dr. Maneck Bhagat. As such, I was not qualified even to hold a scalpel, let alone cut through the brains of living persons.  But, Drs. Desai and Dastur, Sunil and the neurosurgery resident staff exuded a lively atmosphere pursuing pure academia. I don’t recall wasting any time with idle talks, the so called “gappa”!

Dr. Desai led weekly EEG reading sessions. The entire department participated. Dr. Desai had received an US-funded PL480 grant to study epilepsy. As part of that study, he carried out sleep EEG studies in epileptic patients and non-epileptic volunteers, mostly medical students like me. Besides serving as a volunteer for the overnight sleep study I also served as tech monitoring EEGs of sleeping participants. During the EEG reading sessions, Sunil was an active participant. His knowledge of neuroanatomy greatly contributed to the discussion on art of localizing pathological regions in the brain at a time no one had imagined either CT scans or MRI.

During the mid-1960s, Dr. Desai went to Japan and learnt from Prof. Hirataro Narabayashi, the technique of stereotaxic surgery to treat patients suffering from basal ganglion disorders. With the help of pneumoencephalography and cerebral angiography, Dr. Dastur and Sunil would carryout the basal ganglion stimulation or ablation (I am not sure which!), under Dr. Desai’s guidance. Such impeccable patient care led to stunning results for conditions declared uncurable elsewhere. The reputation of KEM Neurosurgery department skyrocketed. Of course, as a postgraduate student, I was a silent witness to such great team work and a beneficiary to enjoy the benefits from their altruistic endeavors.  

Then there were highly educational “brain cutting” sessions. Typically, we would have two or three “brains” to cut. The sessions were organized along the lines of CPC.  Either Sunil, or one of the neurosurgery residents would present the clinical aspects of the case, and if there were surgeries, Sunil described the details of the surgical procedures. Then the neuropathologist, Dr. D. H. Deshpande, would go over the general autopsy findings, and in a brutally slow tempo, dissect the brain to reveal all the secrets clinicians and radiologists had missed. What superb training sessions they were! Dr. Dastur held Sunil at highest esteem. He sought Sunil’s concurrence on academic matters. And, always, Sunil’s inputs were mature, thoughtful, productive and to-the-point.

Few elements of my professional work at KEM required Sunil’s assistance. I had to write a thesis for to become eligible to take my Pediatrics MD examination. I chose muscular dystrophy in children as my topic for the thesis and Sunil was the surgeon performing muscle biopsies on my patients. Thus, Sunil remained a steadfast mentor, guide, and above all a trustworthy friend.

The neurosurgery ward under Drs. Desai, Dastur and Sunil was one of most efficiently run programs I ever saw. Those days (I am talking about the 1970s), the medical records department at KEM was a place of near disaster. It might take hours to retrieve a record, or we would learn that someone had borrowed the same. However, Dastur, Desai, and Sunil developed an entirely self-contained medical records system, which Sunil says in one of his writings, “….was unparalleled in India.” Using no more than pens, papers, log books and library-cards, with minimal efforts one could pullout an entire medical record document of any patient, if he or she had been in their department beyond the year 1957. 

Sunil wrote in an essay that that it would take about 5 minutes to retrieve such data from their medical records system. If a patient had been seen even for a brief visit, her medical records would have an entry in an incredibly sophisticated library card system. You consulted a log book that provided the information about where that patient’s record had been saved—which filing cabinet, which shelf number, and how many records—all can be traced using the card system. All that you needed was the name of the patient and the year in which the patient was seen in the neurosurgery department. The records included case notes, care summaries of each visit, x-ray films with formal reports by the radiologist, EEG records and interpretation, pathology reports, follow-up notes, including, when applicable, autopsy findings.

Before there were computers this was a unique approach to keeping medical records. Importantly, Sunil would write most comprehensive clinical notes for each patient seen on that day before returning home.  He had an impeccably wonderful handwriting. Nothing would be left for anyone’s imagination. Being thorough in every aspect of the work he did was Sunil’s greatest attribute.

Sunil’s neurosurgery office also boasted an impressive library. Dr. Desai was the Editor-in-Chief for Neurology India –so we had all issues of that journal. Plus, Dr. Dastur brought all neurology and neurosurgery journals he had subscribed to. And, there were dozens of most recent editions of books on neurosciences. I was told that besides Drs. Dastur, and Desai, Sunil too was largely responsible for enriching that library.  

In the library, there were some books, which were my favorite: Garrisson’s History of Neurology, Arturo Castiglioni’s A History of Medicine, Russel Brain’s Some Reflections on Genius and Other Essays, and Harry Wain’s The Story Behind the Word. When I came to the US and when was able to purchase those books, they were the first 4 books I ordered for my personal library.  I have copied the cover pages of these books, for those of who may be interested in seeing those!

After I came to the US, Sunil and I we were separated by two continents, pressures of work and other usual inconveniences of academicians’ lives. But I used to make it a point to visit Sunil at KEM, if my travel plans and  the itinerary allowed a visit to Mumbai.

After the evolution of internet and the email systems, we linked more often. We began exchanging our mutual passion—reading and writing on the history and ethics of medicine. We were both admirers of Sir William Osler. As a card-carrying member of American Osler Society, I was able to send the Oslerian newsletter to Sunil. I had published two books on the history of medicine, which I believe, I sent him by postal mail. And he wrote to me about those books and his own 2018 classic, Medical Education in Western India: Grant Medical College and Sir Jamshedji Jeejeebhoy’s Hospital.

We exchanged other writings, too. I was deeply touched reading his tribute to Dr. Anil Desai in Obituary—Dr. Anil D. Desai (1924-2006) In Neurology, India, January-March vol 55, page 94-95, 2007 (also available at TSpace by University of Toronto). I still remember the opening paragraph of the obituary: “Dr. Anil Desai died on 30 August 2006 as he had desired—with his boots on and still in harness. After a pleasant lunch with his friends, as he walked towards his car he suddenly passed away.”

His deep-seated interest in the history and ethics of medicine were other reasons for our continued connection. Sometimes, he would ask me to send copies of papers he had difficulty in finding, which was easy for me to obtain from the National Library of Medicine System, for I have an account there. And, I always enjoyed his brilliantly-written articles on history of medical education systems in India, with focus on Mumbai.

You may be wondering why am I meandering describing “other matters” about Sunil, when I am paying tribute to him. Well, precisely because, I want to show how much intellectual and spiritual debt I owe Sunil. Always asking myself, “…How would Sunil respond to this [crisis, situation, fill in the blank]?”.  I want to underscore how deep was his influence, impacting the wide-eyed lives of postgraduate students like me.

Now, having written this much, it is extremely difficult for me to conclude my brief tribute to Sunil, because I am still grieving.  It is difficult to refer to Sunil in past tense. But there are times when we must do the inevitable: mourn our closest of friends.

So, these are a few of my words offered as homage to my dear friend Sunil Pandya.

Titles of books at KEM neurosurgery department library I read and bought them in the US.

I first met Sunil Pandya in 2005 or so when I had organized an ethics conference in collaboration with the Christian Medical College in Vellore. At the time I was at the University of Texas, San Antonio. Sunil with his long time interest in medical ethics was naturally someone I thought of because he was well published in this field in India; I invited him to Vellore to be one of our guest speakers. We became friends and correspondents over the years.

Years later, when I was writing my novel THE COVENANT OF WATER which involved a fair bit of neurosurgery, Sunil was a wonderful resource, patiently teaching me the elements of the kind of neurosurgical procedures that would’ve been available in rural India in the 60s and 70s, and going over relevant parts of my manuscript. At his invitation, I also gave a video lecture to honor one of your past faculty members.

I am very sad to hear of his passing. He truly was a Renaissance man, combining his skills in neurosurgery with a broad interest in the humanities and arts, and all of this combined with a tremendous love and commitment to the institution where he trained, and to his colleagues and students. Any one of us would be proud to have made the kinds of contributions that impacted so many in one lifetime. My condolences to his family and to you, his colleagues. Rest in peace, Sunil, my friend.

I felt privileged to have interacted with Dr. Sunil Pandya, one of the most renowned neurosurgeons in the country, during recent years. What I was deeply touched by was his focus on humanity and ethics. He was a pioneer in developing and promoting medical humanities. He was the Editor of an inspiring journal – the Indian Journal of Medical Ethics. In an article Dr. Pandya published on “Turning Points in My Medical Career”, he wrote about how much he learned from his own mentors and colleagues, but especially from his patients. “Most of all, I have learned from my patients, especially the poor patients who sought our help. The gratitude they showed and affection they showered were humbling.”

Dr. Pandya emphasized the importance of passing on to the younger generation the need to keep learning and practice ethically, and keeping the welfare of the patient in mind all the time. He wanted trainees to continue the ancient tradition of “guru-shishya parampara”. Dr. Pandya was a shining light in Indian medicine for decades, and his legacy will continue forever.

Sunil Pandya, was an extraordinary human being whose impact as a neurosurgeon and mentor will resonate for generations. His unwavering vision and dedication to cultivating future clinicians exemplified his commitment to the advancement of science and the art of healing.

Professor Pandya’s legacy is not just in the surgical skills he imparted, but in the humanistic approach he championed, reminding us all of the profound connection between science and compassion in the delivery of care. His presence will be deeply missed, but his influence will forever inspire those he touched.

A Tribute to Prof. Dr. Sunilkumar Krishnalal Pandya

Born: 11th February 1940
Died: 17th December 2024

Prof. Dr. Sunil Pandya’s remarkable journey began with his education at JJ Hospital and continued to his influential tenure at KEM Hospital and Seth GSMC. His life exemplified dedication to excellence in neurosurgery and profound mentorship to countless students and colleagues.

Academic Milestones

Dr. Pandya achieved all academic milestones with distinction, completing his MBBS and MS in General Surgery at the first attempt. His honors include numerous scholarships and medals:

Early Career and Mentorship

After gaining experience as a house surgeon in various specialties, including general surgery and orthopedics,  Dr. Pandya served as a registrar in neurosurgery under Dr. Gajendra Sinh. In 1967, he joined KEM Hospital as an Assistant Professor under Dr. H.M. Dastur.

Dr Pandya was appointed Professor of Neurosurgery and Head of Department in 1974. Dr. Pandya’s mentorship style left an indelible mark: he was welcoming, ever-encouraging, and a stickler for detailed history and examination. Residents vividly recall his clear diction, impeccable English, and the precision with which he conveyed complex concepts.

Dr. Pandya’s office was always accessible to residents, symbolizing his open-door policy. The department library housed books from his personal collection, donations, and reviewed journals, which he trusted residents to use responsibly. Remarkably, not a single book ever went missing.

He took pride in acknowledging accomplishments, no matter how small, and was known to compliment his colleagues and trainees at the drop of a hat. His mentorship often extended beyond neurosurgery, guiding mentees in their professional and personal lives.

Interdisciplinary Collaboration:

He also encouraged interdisciplinary collaboration, such as working with Dr. Milind Kirtane to develop endoscopic repair techniques for CSF leaks, significantly reducing the need for invasive craniotomies. Collaboration with Prof K S Goleria led to development of reconstruction in Craniostenosis and Craniofacial deformities.  Collaboration with Profs Shekhar Bhojraj and  Vinod Laheri led to development of spinal surgery.  Collaboration with Prof Nilima Kshirsagar led to creation of Liposomal tagged Amphotericin  for treatment of fungal infections. Medical ICU was founded  with Prof Dilip Karnad.

Contributions to Medical Ethics & Forum for Medical Ethics Society

Dr. Pandya made significant contributions to the Indian Journal of Medical Ethics. He was instrumental in shaping the discourse on ethical medical practices in India, using his platform to advocate for transparency, patient rights, and the moral responsibilities of medical professionals. His writings combined rigorous ethical analysis with practical insights, inspiring a generation of healthcare practitioners to prioritize ethics alongside clinical excellence.

Philosophy and Vision

Dr. Pandya’s philosophy revolved around selflessness and collaboration. He often assigned prestigious opportunities to his colleagues and mentees, enabling them to shine. For instance, when offered a fellowship in Germany, he sent a colleague instead, setting an example of generosity and humility.

His trust in others was evident in his open-door policy and the culture he fostered within the department. He was known for his unwavering commitment to excellence, pushing his team to achieve the extraordinary while ensuring they always had his guidance and support.

Legacy and Recognition

Dr. Pandya’s leadership and academic contributions have been documented in his book, The Neurological Society of India: Retrospect and Prospect. His efforts in fostering innovation, mentorship, and collaboration have left an indelible mark on Indian neurosurgery. His numerous contributions to the field—from groundbreaking surgical techniques to infrastructure development—reflect his vision of making neurosurgery accessible and effective for all.

Prof. Dr. Sunil Pandya will always be remembered as a towering figure in Indian neurosurgery—a mentor, innovator, and selfless leader. His life and work continue to inspire generations, reminding us of the profound impact one individual can have on an entire field.

He is survived by his wife, Shubhada, herself a trained Neuro-Physiologist of repute. His son Nirad lives and works in the USA. His daughter Anandi, lives and works with her family in Delhi.

I was associated with Dr. Sunil K Pandya since 1970 until his passing. Initially I saw him as an academician who was a genuine peer of the writings that Dr. Manu Kothari and I collaborated on. He was dedicated, determined, disciplined, diligent and devoted to his work. He was very methodical and organized in his work. His interest in history was unsurpassed. He enthralled medical students at Seth G S Medical College and KEM Hospital year after year with his talks on the history of Anatomy in particular, and Medicine in general. He was largely responsible in setting up the archives, entitled Janus at Seth G S Medical College and KEM Hospital. To top the list of his contributions, besides being an excellent neurosurgeon and astute clinician, he became the first Chairperson of Dr. Manu V L Kothari Chair and Division of Medical Humanities. He shaped this division and gave it structure. The division carried out various multifaceted programs, including, the conference ‘’Ascension’’ an annual event which is totally organized by students and publication of the annual report as well as bringing out a volume on the theme of medical humanities. He had vision. He relinquished this post in April, 2024 because of his failing health.

Personally, I was a great beneficiary of his generosity. He supported me fully, spending enormous time to help complete and publish our seven books and new editions of four books after the sudden passing away of Dr. Kothari.

Dr. Sunil Panya lived his professional life to perfection.

From examining patients in the outpatient clinics through to writing detailed operation notes – liberally illustrated with diagrams, SKP as we fondly called him,  was a man who short- changed no one.

What got us together was neuroradiology. This blossomed into a close relationship as close s could be between a student and a teacher maturing to one between two colleague that lasted for a little less than half a century.

His caring for me and mentoring has such an impact that I have considered him as my role model – ahead of everyone else.

Time came and both of us had retired from KEM hospital, but our interactions continued. Off and on, we would meet over breakfast, the breakfast conversation would leave me enriched on the “right things to do in life” After all, SKP was the epitome of ethical practices in his medical and personal life.

In the last decade or so, the field of Medical Humanities brought us closer together – a field that was already a way of life for him.

His final contribution to the institutions that he served for so long and so well was a detailed volume on the History of GS Medical College and KEM hospital; to be released the occasion of the centenary celebrations of these institutions early next year. Do not miss this jewel for anything. The details and the meticulousness with which this volume has been written is what SKP is all about.

And finally, for SKP, the pronoun “I” never existed, it was always a “We”…  credit shared with others.

A chronic illness debilitated an otherwise healthy man in his 80s. We have a lost a man, the like of whom, we will not see…. in a long, long time.

Dr. Sunil K. Pandya

A Luminary in Medicine and Medical Humanities

It is with profound sadness and a deep sense of loss that I reflect on the passing of Dr. Sunil Pandya, an extraordinary neurosurgeon, mentor, and a pioneering force in medical humanities at KEM Hospital. His departure leaves an immense void in our medical community, yet his legacy continues to illuminate our path forward. Though I was never formally his student, I learned immensely from him through various forums and personal interactions.

As the founding Chair of the Humanities Cell at KEM Hospital, Dr. Pandya envisioned medicine as an intricate blend of science and human experiences. He believed that truly effective healers embrace both the technical precision of medicine and the compassionate understanding of healthcare’s human dimensions. Under his leadership, the Humanities Cell became a vibrant hub for intellectual discourse, ethical reflection, and the cultivation of empathy in medical practice.

Dr. Pandya was not just a senior colleague and teacher but also a mentor whose wisdom profoundly influenced me. He approached ethical dilemmas with a rare blend of intellectual rigor and deep humanity. Almost every day, he shared his “Wisdom Mail,” a treasure trove of articles, thoughts, and life lessons that enriched all who received them. Whether discussing complex cases or addressing systemic healthcare challenges, he consistently emphasized the importance of maintaining a strong moral compass amidst the complexities of modern medicine.

As the Head of the Department of Neurosurgery at KEM Hospital, Dr. Pandya’s contributions extended beyond his surgical expertise. He fostered an environment of excellence where young doctors were encouraged to question, learn, and grow. His department became a beacon of clinical expertise, ethical standards, and humanitarian care.

What truly set Dr. Pandya apart was his ability to bridge the worlds of clinical practice and medical humanities. He understood that the finest doctors are those who combine technical mastery with emotional intelligence and ethical awareness. Through his countless discussions, lectures, and personal interactions, he shaped the perspectives of generations of medical professionals.

As the current Chair of the Humanities Cell, I feel a profound responsibility to carry forward his vision. Dr. Pandya showed us that medicine, at its best, is both an art and a science, with humanitarian values as essential as clinical skills. His intellectual legacy continues to inspire our approach to medical education and practice.

Today, while we mourn his loss, we also celebrate a life dedicated to advancing medicine and medical humanities. Dr. Pandya’s influence lives on through the countless lives he touched, the department he nurtured, and the humanitarian ideals he instilled. His passing reminds us of our duty to uphold the principles he championed – excellence in clinical practice, unwavering ethics, and compassion for those we serve.

May his soul rest in peace, and may his ideals guide us in our pursuit of medical excellence and humanitarian care. We will miss you, Sir!

My homage to Dr. Sunil Pandya

I feel I am really fortunate to have known the GS Medical College alumni due to my association with Medical Humanities.
At the same time I think I was unfortunate not to be their student.

Dr. Sunil Pandya’s strength of character blended with his soft nature was unique and apt to become the chair of Medical
Humanities in Seth G.S. Medical College.
There was so much to learn just by watching and hearing him.

Working with him might have been so enriching.I learnt so many more facets of his persona when I was listening to the thoughts expressed by many members of Forum for Medical Ethics Societies here.
I regret I did not make the best of the learning opportunity I had when we were associated with him.

Farewell  Dr. Pandya

I think its unfair to give a title to Dr. Pandya like “Gandhian” I would prefer to use word “Pandyian” as he was unique in many ways. Allow me to describe my encounters with Dr. Pandya, which will highlight and underline his presence in molding our lives, helping us to set our goal, showing us the direction, discipline, knowledge and the skill set necessary not only to be a good doctor OR Good Neurosurgeon but also a good and honest human being!

Dr Pandya – The Mentor

My first meeting with the Giant of a man!

After I finished my Masters in General Surgery I was advised to meet Dr Sunil Pandya who would help me decide on where I was to do my residency in neurosurgery. After a brief meeting where I could barely open my mouth as I kept gazing at one of the FOREMOST Neurosurgeons in the country, I was told to attempt the entrance for Sree Chitra Tirunal Institute of Medical Sciences and Technology. He stated that it would be in my interest to work there as I could always work in Mumbai later as I was a resident from here!  It was Dr Pandya who was instrumental in me studying neurosurgery at Shri Chitra Tirunal Institute which he said was very different from any other institutions in the country as its GOALS were

1. Research frist namely experimental work and research, Including animal models
2. MCH program and teaching and
3. Patient care and service of humanity  in that order and therefore it allowed  maximum growth of Young budding neurosurgeon

In addition, it had teachers from whole country, as this institution was started as act of Parliament for top class research and student education.

Dr Pandya knew best – though I sulked at not being asked to join his department He was sure I should do my MCh Neuro at SCTIMST!

I should like to add that Dr Pandya was my examiner in my MCh neurosurgery exams as well one of my toughest exams I have face in my entire life. (the other being my M C A umpires exams in Cricket! )

After finishing my MCH, I was invited to join my alma mater which was also Dr. Pandya’s alma mater. As nobody wanted to leave Dr. Pandya’s formidable team  at KEM Neurosurgery which was Dr. Pandya , Dr. Nagpal , Dr.Tarapurkar a trio par excellance, the  guiding force of neurosurgery ,one of the best in India. I even went for selection process in the BMC where Dr. Pandya was in the panel but there were no empty posts at KEM Hospital. I was fortunate that there was an opening at Sion. Again, Dr. Pandya insisted that I should work there, as Chitra training was not robust in Spine and my stint in SION Hospital would stand me in good stead. Then, as they say fortune favors the brave Dr. Parischa (who was lecturer at KEMH) wanted to work with Dr. Ramani  at Sion , I was keen to work with Dr. Pandya and join KEM neurosurgery . I was therefore fortunate that a mutual exchange was feasible and my wish was fulfilled.

Dr Pandya – Pandyian Style

Let me narrate my encounter an with Dr. Pandya at my first NSI meeting at Indore 1990-91 (For those who don’t know, NSI is the Neurosurgical Surgical Society Of India , which hold annual meetings in different cities of country and the meeting is attended by most Heads of National Institutions making meeting an academic feast ! ). Dr. Pandya Professor and Head of Seth G S M C and K E M Hospital was presenting, standing at podium with bunch of papers. withThere were no slides or any other props to help him with presentation. The case was that of “ Tuberculous meningitis and It’s Sequelae” and I was in the audience in a packed auditorium, keen to listen to what Dr. Pandya had to say!. My chief from the National Institute where I did my neurosurgery, Shri Chitra Tirunal Institute, Trivandrum was sitting at the first row, Dr. Raut. Dr. Pandya was looking through his notes and was reading out CSF report of the patient. He mentioned the CSF sugar values but failed to mention the corresponding blood sugar levels of patient. Dr. Raut known to be an aggressive personality, interrupted Dr. Pandya’s presentation asking for corresponding sugar values. Dr. Pandya Began shuffling through his papers could not find that report and mentioned to audience, he was sorry that the details were not available at that moment. It was important being a very basic information with a lot of clinical relevance; it was easy for Dr. Pandya to give a value which would serve the purpose as this was clear cut case of meningitis, however, Dr. Pandya’s Honesty and Integrity was evident even though he had failed to prove very pertinent academic point. As a young resident in Neurosurgery this made a huge mark in my set of values! For this, Dr. Pandya deserved a standing ovation, his was the only presentation without use of slides. He was the only professor in the auditorium, who was dressed in a white shirt and white trouser, He was a leader and head of KEM neurosurgery (One the leading foremost leading neurosurgical Center in the country).

Dr Pandya The Head of K E M Neurosurgery My HOD!

My First Day at work was complete different with Dr. Pandya. I was already a senior lecturer by then (Over 3 years Post MCH), However Dr. Pandya insisted that I manage the OPD and the wards for 3 months and only then I will enter theatre, as luck would have it within few weeks our resident doctors went on strike and there was young adult large intraventricular Tumor who was admitted in drowsy state, being around in the department for most of the time, Dr. Pandya instructed to me to operate. I can still picture him sitting in a neurosurgery office which was actually a library asking me if  I could manage the patient as I won’t be having any help as no residents were available and there began a new chapter in my life , Thanks to Dr. Pandya.

Interactions with Dr. Pandya were invariably directed towards department or work issues directed towards patient care; very rarely seeking anything for self or entertainment. His principles were set high, he had no nonsense attitude.

When he was to retire in 1998, he started to hand over “all his efforts” over the years to the next in line which took him over a year! He weaned off most surgeries, allotting cases to next in lines. He even decided to manage the OPD single handedly as we had daily OPD’S. And those fortunate few that have read his outpatients records namely clinical history and medical examinations  will bare me out; acknowledging the fact that each would be a manuscript in itself and a lesson for a residents in the art of neurology and neurosurgery. Moments we shared with him were priceless. Lessons we learnt. All I can say is that it was Pandyian Style!

Dr Pandya The Human

We knew very little of Dr Pandyas family life and his other joys but I clearly remember one of his many faithfuls use to jokingly say that whenever he went to Dr Pandya’s home which was on the ground floor of the A D bungalow just nbehind the hospital premise he would be watching Fashion T V !  He would sometimes ask about my vintage car which would be parked in the campus in the garage facing his home. I would speak to his wife if I ever called his residence but that was all. He would very rarely enjoy a glass of Beer but that’s about all I could say about his likes.

This was way back in 1998, He had but one wish, which I learnt off when I become head of this fabled institution which was to be Professor Emeritus at KEM Neurosurgery. I was shocked to learn that he was not invited for the same by the next Head nor the DEAN of the institution. His handover which had commenced a year before he retired allowed the department to grow, which tell us about the greatness of the man and love and caring for department of Neurosurgery he nurtured for such a long time at KEM Hospital.

I am sure that he will continue to guide KEM neurosurgery and all his residents and staff while he spends the rest of his life from up there!

I knew Dr Sunil Pandya since my residency in Neurology from 1970. Of course that was a very formal connect, to refer our patients and discuss.

More connections started from 1983, when I became HOD Neurology. We understood each other and interdepartmental relationship became very amicable. The biggest outcome was creation of the Neuro ICU with our joint efforts and first of its kind in BMC, as a project of private-public partnership. Our connections were more friendly after we both retired. We often had long conversations about life, general knowledge and literature.

He was an inspiration to me. I appreciate his simplicity, honesty, ethics and humility. His talks always made other person feel bigger and great. I truly appreciate his detailed notes with beautiful handwriting. He repeatedly reminded me of our Epilepsy work and writing about it. He knew about my family, my roller coaster journey and inspired me to write my story. Result was my book titled as INSPIRATION TO ACTION. Whenever I am stuck with some problem, I took his guidance and he was always ready to help.

So for me, I have lost a Friend, Philosopher and Guide. Neuoscience has lost a great historian and an Ideal role model. May his soul rest in peace.